Wishes Are Cheap, Plans Are Not: The Science of Actually Doing the Thing
Why a pleasant daydream can work against you
It seems obvious that picturing a happy outcome should help us achieve it. The research by the psychologist Gabriele Oettingen and colleagues suggests that it can do the opposite. In several studies, people who spent time fantasizing positively about a future goal, such as landing a job or losing weight, tended to put in less effort and achieve less than people who were less rosy in their daydreams.
One explanation is that vivid positive fantasy lets the brain enjoy a taste of success in advance, which reduces the energy we feel for the hard work in between. As with many findings in this area, the size of the effect varies, but the pattern is a useful warning against confusing daydreaming with progress.
Mental contrasting: add the obstacle
Oettingen's alternative is called mental contrasting. You imagine the outcome you want, and then you imagine the main obstacle inside you that stands in the way, such as tiredness, distraction, or the temptation to stay on the sofa. Pairing the dream with a realistic obstacle seems to help people decide whether a goal is worth pursuing and to commit more strongly when it is.
This approach has been packaged into a simple method often called WOOP, standing for wish, outcome, obstacle, and plan. You name the wish, picture the best result, identify the real obstacle, and then make a plan for dealing with it. The whole exercise takes a few minutes, which is part of its appeal.
If-then plans: decide in advance
The psychologist Peter Gollwitzer has studied what he calls implementation intentions, which are plans of the form if situation X happens, then I will do Y. A meta analysis of many studies found that people who made such plans were substantially more likely to follow through on their goals than people who only intended to.
The idea is that the plan hands the decision to the situation. Instead of deciding at 7 p.m. whether you feel like exercising, you have already decided that when you get home from work, you will put on your running shoes. It removes a negotiation with yourself, and negotiations with yourself are not an area in which most of us do very well.
A small way to start this week
Pick one wish, not five. Write the version of it that is small enough to do in twenty minutes, and then write one if-then plan for when and where you will do it. For example, if I finish my morning coffee, then I will practice the guitar for ten minutes.
Then make it easier to begin than to avoid. Leave the guitar out of its case, set a timer, and tell yourself you only have to stay for ten minutes. Wishes are cheap, and there is nothing wrong with having a long list. The trick is to move one of them, just one, from the list into the calendar.
In Short
Positive daydreaming alone can sap effort. Mental contrasting and if-then plans, studied by Oettingen and Gollwitzer, help turn wishes into action. Choose one wish, make it small, and decide when and where you will do it.
Try a Focused Session
Cadenzato is a free timer with ambient sound and a calm countdown. No login needed.
Open the Timer →